Chapter 3 - Two difficult elders discover they are not difficult with each other
Thomas woke at six.
So did I.
Neither of us admitted this was convenient.
I found him standing in the kitchen in a pale blue shirt and dark trousers, staring suspiciously at my coffee grinder.
“Touch it and lose a finger.”
“I was merely observing.”
“That is what burglars say.”
He stepped aside.
Breakfast was toast, eggs, coffee for me, tea for him.
He ate marmalade.
I did not trust that either.
But an odd thing happened over the course of the morning.
Nothing happened.
No conflict.
No crisis.
No need for supervision.
Thomas read the newspaper without spreading it across my table like territorial property. He rinsed his cup. He asked before adjusting the thermostat. When I sat down at the piano, he quietly moved into the living room and listened without comment until I finished.
Then he said:
“Your left hand rushes slightly when you’re angry.”
I turned on the bench.
“My left hand does no such thing.”
“It did during the Schubert.”
“You critique your host?”
“You played it at me.”
I almost laughed.
“James used to say the same thing.”
Thomas’s expression softened.
“Your husband?”
I nodded.
That was how we began talking about the dead.
He had been married to Margaret for forty-three years.
She played violin.
He still had her instrument.
Had not opened the case in almost eight years.
“Because you’re afraid it will sound wrong?”
“Because I’m afraid it will sound exactly right.”
That answer silenced me.
Some grief is too accurate for conversation.
So I played something quieter.
Thomas sat near the window.
When I finished, neither of us filled the room with sympathy.
That was the first thing I liked about him.
He understood silence.
At lunch, Clara called.
Thomas answered.
I pretended not to listen.
“You comfortable?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“Eleanor behaving?”
My head turned.
Thomas’s did too.
“I beg your pardon?”
Clara laughed.
“I’m joking.”
“No,” Thomas said mildly. “You were checking.”
There was a pause.
“We just know she can be particular.”
He looked at me.
I raised one eyebrow.
“And I?” he asked.
“What?”
“What did you tell Eleanor about me?”
Clara’s tone changed.
“Nothing bad.”
“That was not the question.”
Another pause.
Then she laughed again, too lightly.
“Oh, you know. That you like things a certain way.”
Thomas ended the call five minutes later.
He did not look angry.
He looked embarrassed.
Not for himself.
For her.
“That,” he said, “was illuminating.”
“They warned each of us about the other.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“To make any friction seem expected.”
I stared at him.
Then suddenly we both understood.
If I complained:
Of course. Eleanor is difficult.
If Thomas complained:
Of course. Thomas is impossible.
If we fought, the family’s assessment was proven.
If we tolerated each other, perhaps something else was proven.
But what?
That afternoon, we began testing our assumptions.
I called Willow Pines.
Not pretending to be anyone else.
Just asked whether holiday guest accommodations existed.
“Yes,” the receptionist said brightly. “We still have availability through Monday.”
I looked at Thomas.
He looked toward the ceiling.
There had never been a housing emergency.
Then he called Gerald Foster, a longtime friend at Willow Pines.
“No fumigation,” Gerald confirmed. “A pipe repair happened in B Wing last week, but Thomas’s building wasn’t affected.”
After Thomas hung up, the kitchen seemed unnaturally bright.
David and Clara had not simplified a bad situation.
They had invented one.
Thomas poured more tea.
“Mrs. Harris.”
“Yes?”
“I believe we have graduated from foolishness to design.”
I looked at our notes on the table.
Then at the calendar.
Thanksgiving cruise.
Four days.
Two older people known by their family as “difficult.”
Placed together under separate false stories.
A test.
The idea sounded paranoid until I remembered the care with which the lies had been tailored.
Then my phone buzzed.
A message from David:
How’s Day One of the experiment? 😂
Three seconds later, it disappeared.
He had unsent it.
May you like
But not before I read it.
Cliffhanger: David accidentally sent Eleanor a message calling the arrangement an “experiment”—then deleted it immediately, confirming that whatever the family had planned was larger than a convenient Thanksgiving favor.
Related Stories
